What began as a meaningful family moment on Memorial Day ended in unimaginable heartbreak for one Laguna Beach family. James Politoski, a 64-year-old beloved father and long-time resident of the coastal city, was tragically killed on Monday, May 26, 2025, while supervising his teenage daughter’s driving practice. The fatal crash occurred just before 5:00 p.m. near the intersection of Laguna Canyon Road and El Toro Road — a busy area often traveled by those learning to drive.
According to authorities, Politoski was in the front passenger seat, guiding his daughter during a supervised driving lesson when the vehicle was involved in a multi-car collision. Early reports indicate that another vehicle, traveling at a high rate of speed, veered into their lane in what investigators believe may have been a result of distracted or impaired driving. The impact was severe. Politoski bore the brunt of the collision and sustained critical injuries. Emergency crews rushed to the scene, and he was transported to a local hospital where he later succumbed to his injuries.
His daughter, whose name is being withheld due to her age, suffered non-life-threatening injuries and is recovering physically — though the emotional scars will linger far longer. Police are continuing to investigate the circumstances surrounding the crash, and charges against the other driver are under consideration pending toxicology results and further evidence.
A Father’s Love Remembered
James Politoski was more than just a victim in a tragic crash — he was a devoted father, a loyal friend, and a deeply respected member of the Laguna Beach community. Friends and neighbors say he had been eagerly looking forward to teaching his daughter how to drive, seeing it not only as a parental responsibility but as a bonding experience. “He talked about it all the time,” said family friend Linda Carson. “He wanted to make sure she learned the right way — calmly, safely, and with confidence. He was the kind of dad who always showed up.”
James had lived in Laguna Beach for over 30 years. He was a retired architect known for his meticulous craftsmanship and contributions to several prominent local buildings. His volunteer work in coastal conservation efforts and youth mentorship programs made him a familiar and cherished figure in the community.
“James was the type of person who quietly made the world better,” said neighbor and city council member Evan Ramirez. “He mentored young people in design and architecture, helped clean our beaches, and never missed a city volunteer day. Losing him like this is a shock to all of us.”
A Community in Mourning
The news of his sudden passing has left a deep void in the heart of Laguna Beach. Local organizations, including the Laguna Beach Historical Society and the High School Parent-Teacher Association, have issued statements mourning the loss. A memorial vigil is being planned at Main Beach Park this weekend, where community members will gather to honor Politoski’s life with stories, music, and a candlelight procession.
Counselors and grief support groups have also been made available to students and families at the high school his daughter attends. “Our hearts are with her,” said Principal Sharon Hall. “She is part of our family, and we will surround her with all the support and compassion we can offer.”
The Lingering Pain of a Split Second
While the investigation into the crash is still ongoing, officials from the Laguna Beach Police Department have urged drivers to exercise extreme caution, particularly around holidays when road activity is high. “This was a preventable tragedy,” said Lt. Maria Hensley. “Whether it was distracted driving, speeding, or intoxication — someone’s recklessness took away a father, mentor, and friend. This is not just a statistic. It’s a life.”
A Legacy of Grace and Generosity
James Politoski leaves behind his wife of 38 years, Margaret, and their two children. He is also survived by his older brother, a retired teacher from Orange County, and countless friends and colleagues who considered him family. Those who knew him best say his legacy will live on not only through the structures he helped design but through the kindness he extended to everyone he met.
“He had a quiet strength,” said his wife, speaking through tears. “He never wanted the spotlight — just to do good, love his family, and leave the world better than he found it. And that’s exactly what he did.”
A scholarship fund in his name is being established to support students pursuing architecture and design. Donations can be made through the Laguna Beach Arts Foundation.
As Laguna Beach mourns the loss of one of its most cherished residents, there is a collective call to honor James Politoski not just in words, but in action — by slowing down, paying attention, and remembering that every moment on the road carries the weight of countless lives.