In the darkness of a late summer night, a tragic scene unfolded in Fayetteville, North Carolina, shattering the calm of a residential neighborhood. On August 18, 2025, at approximately 10:58 p.m., the Fayetteville Police Department received a distressing call reporting a stabbing in the 4600 block of Rosehill Road, a street nestled across from Warrenwood Elementary School. What officers discovered upon arrival was a grim tableau: a man, gravely wounded, lay inside a home, his life slipping away despite desperate attempts to save him. The victim, now identified as 33-year-old Brian Carter of Fayetteville, would not survive the night.
The incident, as police have revealed, stemmed from a heated altercation inside the residence—a dispute that turned deadly between individuals bound by family ties. The exact nature of the confrontation remains shrouded in mystery, with investigators carefully piecing together the moments that led to such a devastating outcome. When officers arrived at the scene, they found Carter suffering from a severe stab wound. First responders worked tirelessly to stabilize him, but their efforts were in vain. He was pronounced dead at the scene, marking a somber moment for all involved.
As the clock ticked past midnight, the quiet street buzzed with the activity of law enforcement. Multiple officers and a forensics team remained on-site into the early hours of August 19, combing through evidence under the glow of streetlights. The WRAL Breaking News Tracker captured the scene, a stark reminder of the fragility of life and the ripple effects of violence. The investigation, still in its early stages, has yet to yield details about potential charges or the precise circumstances of the altercation. What is known is that this was not a random act—Carter and his assailant were related, adding a layer of heartbreak to an already tragic event.
This fatal stabbing marks Fayetteville’s 29th homicide investigation of 2025, the third in August alone, underscoring a troubling wave of violence in the city. The community, shaken by the loss, now looks to the authorities for answers. Detective J. Bergamine, leading the investigation, is urging anyone with information to come forward. Those who wish to share details can contact him directly at 910-705-2093 or submit tips anonymously through Fayetteville/Cumberland County Crime Stoppers by calling 910-483-TIPS (8477), visiting fay-nccrimestoppers.org, or using the “P3 Tips” mobile app.
As the investigation continues, the memory of Brian Carter lingers in the hearts of those who knew him. On Rosehill Road, where the ordinary rhythm of life was shattered, questions remain: What sparked the fatal dispute? And how will a grieving community find closure? For now, the Fayetteville Police Department presses forward, determined to uncover the truth in a case that has left a family—and a city—forever changed.